Fat Pig/Spelling Bee/Coram Boy/Chicago
Mini-reviews, since I saw so many shows!
-------------
Fat Pig 05/24/07
Geffen Playhouse, Los Angeles
Like most plays tackling tough subjects, Neil LaBute's Fat Pig is more notable for the feelings and questions it provokes in its audience than the quality of material itself. Seemingly a direct transfer from the 2004 off-broadway production, those involved in Fat Pig at the Audrey Skirball Kenis Stage do the best they can with a script that never lives up to its gripping premise.
Of the four characters, only Helen (the "Fat Pig" of the title) is played by an unknown in this production - an effective choice that makes Kirsten Vagness' honest performance all the more heartbreaking. As Tom, who falls in love with Helen, Scott Wolf ("Party of Five," "Everwood") has a genuine air about him that seems to disguise or at least excuse the fact that his delivery often made LaBute's natural dialogue sound stiff or stilted. And his colleagues Andrea Anders ("The Class," "Joey") and Chris Pine ("Princess Diaries 2," "Smokin' Aces") provide the antagonism and comic relief with such realism that you wonder why you find yourself agreeing with their prejudiced statements more often than you should.
LaBute's writing is quick and realistic, but the structure of only a handful of scenes robs the characters, actors and audience of believable character arcs and natural progression of emotions.
I'm a geek about sets, so I can't finish this mini-review without raving about it - only two panels that transformed into a cafeteria, an office, a bedroom, a japanese restaurant and a beach, it was masterfully minimal and endlessly adaptable.
The show is entertaining enough for its 100 minutes, but never takes off in a way that great theater does... at least not until you leave the theater and make your first snap judgment. In that respect it succeeds enormously.
-------------
25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee 05/25/07
Wadsworth Theater, Los Angeles
This reunion of the Original Broadway Cast is a very different beast than the show that premiered two years ago at Second Stage and later Circle in the Square. Now each of these characters has been inhabited by a number of different actors, on Broadway, on tour, and at sit-downs in San Francisco, Chicago and Boston. With the show now standing on its own as a commodity, the Original Broadway Cast needed to restake their claim on characters we've seen in so many interpretations. And they may have done so, were the production values up to scratch.
Spelling Bee has always been a charming show that has its weaknesses in its score and very premise - while it provides much opportunity for hilarity, it prevents any real knowledge of the characters beyond their stereotypes and makes narratives outside of the main competition difficult to tell honestly. Of the cast, only Dan Fogler stood out as giving a portrayal unlike anything I'd ever seen or even imagined for the character. He played Barfee as the cockiest motherfucker there ever was, and I'll be damned if it didn't work and provide the biggest laughs in the show.
Unfortunately, the whole production was undermined by horrible sound editing (in the first row of the mezzanine I missed more than a few lines and jokes) and shoddy spotlight operators. Hopefully they'll fix those problems by opening night and Los Angeles can get a chance to fall in love with Spelling Bee. But at six viewings, I think I'm all Spelling Bee-d out.
Celebrity spotting: Leonard Maltin! He actually exists outside of the cover of his movie guide!
-------------
Coram Boy 05/27/07 3pm
Imperial Theater, New York
I've been to two closing nights in New York, both in the Imperial Theater - first High Fidelity in December and now Coram Boy. Running at 40% for most of its run with a cast of over 40, Coram Boy presumably just couldn't justify staying open any longer without the Tony Nom for best play, and it played its final performance today to a sold-out house.
Based on Jamila Gavin's novel, Coram Boy was derided by the critics for using overtly spectacular production values to make up for its weak and melodramatic plot. But its clichéd plot is played with complete honesty and dedication, creating fully realized characters in an old-fashioned yarn that is incredibly entertaining for those in the right frame of mind. As a romantic myself, I smiled with glee at every predictable plot twist and cringed at every predictable foible. I couldn't have loved it more.
The spectacle of the gorgeously effective set (a simple ramp converts any area into the children's playhouse, and the position of the piano indicates whether they are in the world of the children or the adults) combined with the epic qualities of Handel's music provide the theatricality that the novel needed to shine. Most amazing was the fact that every aspect of the production enhanced the story, and none of its amazing elements seemed extraneous or unnecessary. The performances are overall of good quality, and Xanthe Elbrick deserves that Tony Nomination with every tick of characterization she gives the two boys she plays.
It's a real shame that the show closed, or I'd be recommending it to everyone I know.
Celebrity spotting: Randy Harrison of Queer as Folk and Wicked!
-------------
Chicago 05/27/07 7pm
Ambassador Theater, New York
What a difference a decade makes: when Encores! produced Chicago in 1996, it was done under Encores! mission statement of reviving little-known shows with notable scores. In the ten short years that the revival of Chicago has been running, its plot and score is so ingrained in the conscience of this musical theater fan that even upon first viewing it seemed stale. Despite energetic performances and crackling choreography the show never manages to stir any real feelings of excitement in the audience, making an already superficial show seem shallower still.
Of course, Joey Lawrence is the main draw of this cast, holding the fort until Harry Hamlin and Lisa Rinna join the show in mid-June. As a fan of his early music (hey, I was 8 when his first album came out, and don't judge until you've had "I Like the Way (Kick Da Smooth Groove)" cheer you up on a rainy day), I was sceptical as to whether his processed and nasal voice from those recordings would translate to the stage. Surprisingly, his voice is pure and he sounds fantastic on "Razzle Dazzle," the only song of his that seems to fall comfortably within his range. He lacks the power of most Broadway leads, and ends up getting lost when the ensemble joins in, but he stands out on sheer star power. It's Joey Lawrence playing Joey Lawrence playing Billy Flynn, which works surprisingly well.
Understudy Melissa Rae Mahon was on for Roxie, and while she too lacks power in her voice, the only indication that she wasn't normally in the role was the slip in my Playbill. The cast play their roles with verve and amusement, but it may have been this hint of self-awareness that kept me from getting fully involved in the story and characters.
-------------
If it's not patently obvious from the physical distance between the four shows I saw this weekend, I moved from the Los Angeles area to New York on Saturday, and am currently staying at a hostel until I find more permanent accomodation. It couldn't be more surreal.
Labels: theater reviews





